Both sides defend their positions with an enthusiasm that would make Harbaugh proud.
There are enough examples where both sides are right and both sides are wrong that it is an argument that can't be won or lost.
I will admit I joined this site because of the recruiting insight and information and rejoiced every 4 and 5 star commitment and looked with skepticism at every 3 star and less commitment.
Then the reality of not every recruit performing to the level of their ranking on both the high and low level slowly set in to the point where I no longer get too excited or too negative about any recruit.
I now value the insight and information about the progress or lack there of when it comes to the team much more than the recruiting pieces.
There are enough examples where both sides are right and both sides are wrong that it is an argument that can't be won or lost.
I will admit I joined this site because of the recruiting insight and information and rejoiced every 4 and 5 star commitment and looked with skepticism at every 3 star and less commitment.
Then the reality of not every recruit performing to the level of their ranking on both the high and low level slowly set in to the point where I no longer get too excited or too negative about any recruit.
I now value the insight and information about the progress or lack there of when it comes to the team much more than the recruiting pieces.