Sorry dude I disagree - the job of a guard is to control the game and take over when needed, not get rebounds! He is incredibly inconsistent as is Irvin. While I like both of them the problem with both is that neither is ok being "the guy". They don't have that mentality of - no worries, I am taking over the game, give me the ball. I think MAAR is the closest to that we have on this team. Caris was absolutely that guy. Stauskas was that, Burke was that. GR3 was not! As a Jr. PG you should be expected to take over games and develop consistency and neither him nor Irvin have that.
Both are returning next year and the thing with Irvin is that his position can allow him to fade once in a while but Walton as a PG can't really do that. If MAAR continues to improve at the rate he did this year and Wagner can put on another 15lbs of muscle - as well as Donnal - we should be significantly better then this year for sure.
Say what you want - Walton and Irvin have hit their ceilings.