Maize&BlueReview - By The Numbers: Comparing Rutgers & U-M, The Two Oldest Programs In The FBS
Rutgers and Michigan are the two oldest programs in the FBS, having first played in 1869 and 1879, respectively.
michigan.rivals.com
U-M first played in 1879 and Rutgers in 1869. They did not meet for the first time until 2014 though.