ADVERTISEMENT

I don't categorize qb's as the GOAT, etc. I tend to look at qb's in

Reality Man

Heisman
Feb 9, 2002
10,292
176
63
the context of the style/type of qb.

For instance....


I look at one style...Brady/Montana/Bradshaw as pocket passers & game managers.


Marino/Manning/Favre/Kelly/Fouts as gun slingers.


Elway/Rodgers/Staubach as multi faceted qb's.



It's too hard to compare styles. I think these comparisons lend themselves to why guys who throw for a lot of yards don't necessarily win Superbowls.


The more yards and td's thrown in the regular season doesn't necessarily translate into winning against better defenses when teams can adapt to your style of play and have better talent. It doesn't require the defense to become an integral part of winning during the regular season.



Thoughts?



Reality Man
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT