Here's the thing - and SCfanblue hopefully you read this. I know you coach HS football and all that but rankings do matter as far as recruiting is concerned - and seriously man, pick a stance...one day you say recruiting stars does not matter and the next day you say it does
. Statistically teams that recruit more 4-5 stars perform way better on the field and that has held true for years - so unless the "money scheme" of rankings and stats are completely coincidence and have been for years, recruiting rankings do matter. Hoke recruited some talent that played well in HS - meaning they had the athleticism, football IQ, potential, etc in HS and were the cream of the crop - the challenge is they were not developed as well along the journey they took.
I don't think JH's journey to success will take as long as people think because he has inherited some very good talent. Now, he does have some major gaps in skilled positions - like QB, WR, etc because Hoke just felt like a bunch of 300lbs folks was all that was needed to win. I think JH's team will start to perform better and better each and every game. Record's may not indicate our improvement because we have a tough slate this year and next year but I expect the product you see on the field will be really good and I really believe we will be in every single game this year as well.
Do I think "Michigan is all of a sudden the team to beat in the BIG" - absolutely not. Too early to tell, and too soon. Do I think "Michigan will not be an easy or likely W for opposing teams every time they play us" - hell yes. I don't think any team - including OSU and MSU - will now feel like they can waltz in and beat us. We may very well end up 8-4 but those 4 losses won't feel like blowouts but rather I think we will realize we had a chance in each of those 4 games. I am still sticking to my optimism that we end up 10-2 before a great bowl game. I bet you that JH knows that if we somehow go 9-3 but lose to both OSU and MSU, we will get a lot of slack about how we have a ways to go and that does effect the team's confidence. He also knows that if he goes 8-4 and beats both MSU & OSU that has the opposite effect - inconsistent but they will be really good. I do think JH notches a win against at least MSU or OSU if not both - I think the talent gap is not that wide...MSU is not that supremely more talented then we are, etc.
Next week is not a cakewalk for us - we have still not proven we know how to win on the road so that is the first step. After that we face a very good NW defensively that knows how to stop the JH type offenses (see what they did to Stanford). I think that will be a very low scoring defensive battle but if we somehow beat them, I will be brimming with optimism going into the MSU game.