2010 (7-6) = 2012 (8-5), underwhelming but winning season that ends with a loss to an SEC team in a bowl game
2009 (5-7) = 2013 (7-6), Around .500, wheels start falling off around first year QB. Still manage to beat Notre Dame.
2008 (3-9) = 2014 (5-7), Unmitigated disaster, miss bowl, lose games we have no business losing (Toledo, Rutgers)
2007 (9-4) = 2015 (10-3), Start year with a loss, senior QB leads us to decent season which ends with a win over Florida in the Capital One bowl
2006 (10-2) = 2016 (10-3), Promising season in which we dominate our way into the top 3, then end the season in disappointment including a loss to fellow top 3 OSU
2005 (7-5) = 2017 (8-5), Injuries and some bad luck leave us with five losses, leading us to make major assistant coaching changes.
2004 (9-3) = 2018 (10-2), Lose early to Notre Dame, but win out until OSU lead by talented first year QB. Get beaten by seemingly inferior underdog Ohio State.
2009 (5-7) = 2013 (7-6), Around .500, wheels start falling off around first year QB. Still manage to beat Notre Dame.
2008 (3-9) = 2014 (5-7), Unmitigated disaster, miss bowl, lose games we have no business losing (Toledo, Rutgers)
2007 (9-4) = 2015 (10-3), Start year with a loss, senior QB leads us to decent season which ends with a win over Florida in the Capital One bowl
2006 (10-2) = 2016 (10-3), Promising season in which we dominate our way into the top 3, then end the season in disappointment including a loss to fellow top 3 OSU
2005 (7-5) = 2017 (8-5), Injuries and some bad luck leave us with five losses, leading us to make major assistant coaching changes.
2004 (9-3) = 2018 (10-2), Lose early to Notre Dame, but win out until OSU lead by talented first year QB. Get beaten by seemingly inferior underdog Ohio State.